I'm becoming fascinated with drugstore cheapie lines like Prestige, Milani, Jordana, NYC, and Wet n'Wild. Before I start spending money (even cheapie lines add up in $$) I thought I'd query the board on their favorites from these lines.
So far, I love Wet n'Wild Ultimate Minersl Powder Foundation, Wet n'Wild's pencil sharpener, Jane Eye Zing eyeshadows and eye liner pencils, and I've loved Prestige eyeshadows for years.
Any other recs?

I also love the Jane Eye Zings but the color selection is very limited, I'd love it if they had a nice darkish taupe and I just bought the eye liner which is great because it doesn't burn my eyes, same with the shadow. I have returned all Prestige cosmetics I've purchased thus far. I hate their lipstick although everyone raves about it I found it a really hard texture, waxy. I use Jordana lip liners, I love them but the eye liner made my eyes burns. I just bought the Milani eye shadow in the old singles and I really like those too.

I like WnW lipliner in 666 and 712. NYC makes a great brow powder with wax.

I love Jane EyeZings! They recently added 4 new shades to their line :)

Also Jane Blush (in the little round pans) is good -- limited color selection but it goes on great and isn't choppy or too shiny.

I really like the revamped Milani blush in Luminous. The 3 part Wet N Wild palettes are nicely pigmented as are the Milani eyeshadow quads. Those are probably my favorites. I love waiting for the CVS/Walgreens buy one get one free specials and trying a bunch of new stuff from these lines!

I really like Jordana's Eye liners & Lip liners--they are smooth, creamy, & pigmented

--Milani has a nice selection of blushes, palettes, eye shadow quads, & eye shadows

--Rimmel makes nice Soft Kohl Kajal Eye Pencils (especially the one in Jungle Green--it's a beautiful, smooth peacock shade)

:D

Oh yes, the Rimmel Eye Kohls are amazing. I always have two or three around because sometimes I can't Rimmel near me and I throw a hissy if I don't have this exact eyeliner. haha. But nothing else works as good. It's soft and applies easily, wears for a long time, and dirt cheap.

I also like NYC Browzzer eyebrow wax/powder kit.

The Jane Shimmer Bronzers are awesome. I haven't tried any of their other products recently, but I used to really like their eyeshadows.

Milani eyeshadows and blushes, too, are great. Although, since they've repackaged into quads and stuff, I haven't found myself buying anything.

I love the NYC concealer sticks! They get surprisingly good reviews on MUA and they're so cheap (less than $2 or $3).

I love E.L.F. I wore two shadows from one of their quads this weekend and got lots of compliments! I find that they are decently long-lasting, especially since they only cost $1, and the colors are really pretty. I've also used and loved their click-pen glosses (I think they are called Hypershine Gloss).

Oh, wow ... I have lots from the drugstore that I call "things to keep" ;)!

A few of them are:

*Prestige l/l - Oak (my HG, I don't even bother looking at others)
*PF e/s quads - the old school ones, like Metallic Canyon, Metallic Nudes (square casing) ... fabulous pigmentation, can't go wrong shades
*WnW AOS powder
*Revlon ColorStay e/l
*L'oreal loose mineral foundation
*Neutrogena e/s duos (the new ones, exact names I can't recall)
*Maybelline Sky High Curves w/p mascara
*CG Lash Blast w/p mascara (but damn, this is so hard to get off)

There are a lot more, but that's what came to mind at the moment! :)

I'm loving drugstore stuff lately myself. Some faves:

-L'Oreal Voluminous mascara
-Cover Girl Professional and Lash Blast mascaras
-Neutrogena Skinclearing liquid foundation
-Neutrogena Nourishing eyeshadow duos
-Cover Girl Perfect Point Plus eyeliners
-Maybelline eyeshadows (the new formula is superb)
-Rimmel Vinyl lip glosses
-Wet n' Wild H20 Proof eye pencils
-Milani Crystal glosses
-Neutrogena MoistureShine Lip Soothers and Lip Sheers
-Neutrogena Mineral Sheers eyeshadows

etc., etc. :)

My favorite drugstore find is not exactly "cheapie" but in the mid price range. But I think the money is completly worth it. I'm talking about the BeFine skincare company that claims to be "food skin care".
I have two of their products:
-Daily Moisturizer with SPF15 with Rosemary, Pomegrante & Rice
-Night Cream with Cocoa, Millet & Rice Bran
Yummy right? Both products feel great on the skin and sink right in. I recommend giving their stuff a try.

Wet and Wild
1) All over shimmer blush
2) Naive blush (a cute pink)
=> Hated the eye liners and foundation
=> Heard women raving of the lipsticks when I was in the store

Jordana
1) Gold lip liner - I bought it in Myanmar?! It is so beautiful, to use as a eyeliner

Blistex lip balms
1) I use the one in a pot as a lip gloss. Nice taste and cute tub.

-Wet'n'Wild All over Shimmer
-Milani Luminous blush
-pretty much every Milani eyeshadow. I really like Java Bean, Clover, and Illusion

I am a drugstore makeup junkie!

My faves:

-Maxfactor Voluminous W/P Mascara in Rich Black

-Covergirl Perfect Point Plus eyeliner in Charcoal

-Covergirl Cheekers Blush in Soft Plum

_Covergirl Trio E/S in Shimmering Sands

-Wet N' Wild Mega Eyes in Egyptian Sands

-Wet N' Wild all over Illumination

-Neutrogena Lipshine SPF 15 in natural

My favourite drugstore "cheapie" makeup:
WnW All Over Shimmer Blush
WnW Acapulco Glow Bronzer
WnW Sensual Sage e/s single
Cover Girl Super Thick Lash Mascara
Prestige lipliner in Silk
Rimmel lipsticks in Airy Fairy and Birthday Suit (really awesome nude shades)
Bonne Bell Liplites in Cappuccino
Lipsmackers in Vanilla (the most moisturizing flavour)

I really like:
Wet n' Wild #712 liner
Dr. Pepper Lipsmackers in vanilla and Dr. Pepper
PF Organic Wear Tinted Moisturizer
Rimmel Stay Matte Powder
Chicken Poop lipbalm
Burt's Bees Replenishing Lipbalm

I second the recommendation for e.l.f stuff. You can only find a limited selection in drugstores, but I've liked most of what I've tried so far. I'd suggest checking out the website first and reading product reviews.