Hi everyone. I have been having some major problems lately with both my mascara and eyeliner smudging. I have been using a NYC Waterproof mascara and Wet 'n Wild's H20 Proof eyliner. I'm not sure about the waterproof part. That definitely might be true. However, in my experience neither of these are at ALL smudge/budge proof!! So, if you could all please recommend both an eyeliner and a mascara that are TRULY smudge/budge proof I would GREATLY appreciate it!! Thanks! I'm SO sick and tired of having to look in the mirror all throughout the day to check for smudges and fix them and hoping no one else noticed them. :(

I've been reading good things on here about Maybelline's Unstoppable Mascara. However, it sounds like that's more of a lengthening mascara whereas I would prefer more of a volumizing type mascara. So, any recs for a volumizing TRULY budgeproof/smudgeproof mascara would be great! Also, what about Maybelline's Unstoppable Eyeliner? Is that truly budgeproof/smudgeproof? Does anyone know of any truly smudgeproof/budgeproof liquid eyeliners?

Well I use L'Oreal Voluminous WP mascara and I don't have any smudging at all. Sorry, I don't use WP eyeliner so I don't have any suggestions for that one.

Definitely Maybelline's Unstoppable mascara...its the only one that doesn't give me raccoon eyes. I've also had luck with CG Lash Blast Waterproof but its difficult to get off. Lash Blast is a bit more volumizing than Unstoppable.

As for eyeliner, the only smudge proof one I've found in MAC fluidlines..when they do wear off (after a loooong time), they flake instead of smear so its not noticeable.

Definitely Maybelline's Unstoppable for mascara. HTH.

I love CG LashBlast - the regular version lasts all day on me, so I'm sure the WP would be amazing. For e/l, Revlon ColorStay & Prestige Automatic Waterproof work really well.

I love CG LashBlast - the regular version lasts all day on me, so I'm sure the WP would be amazing. For e/l, Revlon ColorStay & Prestige Automatic Waterproof work really well.

I totally agree with all these recs. Lash Blast does last all day without smudging or smearing or giving you racoon eyes. It is difficult to remove, so make sure you have an oil based remover or baby oil handy. For liquid eyeliners, look into Urban Decay. I have so many colors, they are my favorites. Not only do they have unique color choices but they are so easy to apply. And they last all day on me, even without UD PP. Once they dry, they don't budge. I have oily eyelids, so this is impressive to me. =)

Also, what about Maybelline's Unstoppable Eyeliner? Is that truly budgeproof/smudgeproof?

It certainly is not. It's a very poor replacement for their Great Line/Great Wear eyeliner which WAS budge & smudgeproof. I complained about this elsewhere on here. If anyone else knows of an automatic sharpener eyeliner that stays on through a nuclear blast, please share. :)

I really am liking CG lash blast in WP. It is very hard to remove, I use almond oil. Almond oil is really good for your skin, so I figure I'll go with that. There is a mascara that I was really liking before I tried lash blast. Its Maybelline and it is a comb instead of a brush....cant remember the name, but its in WP and its very good. I love the stylie style eyeliner (did i spell that right??) anyway...does not smear, smudge, or barely comes off....also need oil to get off, but It stays all day long and I work with animals so you know I'm getting sweaty and nasty (hee hee) I get the eyeliner at CVS...I don't think I've seen it at my Walgreens
Good luck!!!! *Sheila

I'm also rec'ing MAC Fluidlines even though they're not drugstore. I wear them on my bottom inner rims and they don't budge all day.