I posted a review for MAC's Florabundance Lipglass yesterday. At the time I made it it's own seperate product based on shade.....instead of lumping it with the rest of the Lipglass reviews. I see that it is now lumped with the rest of the Lipglass reviews. I don't know if all products are being lumped together under the product name regardless of shade or not, but I think the option should be there if possible to review them seperately based on the product shade if the reviewer chooses to do them that way. I was reading through the MAC Lipglass reviews for example...and it starts to get really confusing b/c some reviews read "This shade is really great" and blah blah blah, but it never mentions the shade b/c it looks like people reviewed them seperately and then they all got lumped together.

Hey! sorry it's taken so long to answer your question.:(
Our new review system puts all the same products into a brand-specific product name - like MAC Tinted Lipgass. When we came to launch the new iCompact site, we realized that we needed to add a colour sub-category, but Gavin was so overwhelmed with work he just couldn't get to it at the time. He is working on a couple of updates and a color sub-category is one of them.

You are absolutely right that the colours should be easily shown in the review headers. Sorry that it's a little confusing at the moment, but we'll work something better out for ya! :)

No rush to get it done :) Just something I wanted to throw out there.